Pillar Two and ISDS: The Structural Conflict and Treaty Interpretation Pathways to Strengthen the Jurisdictional Bar of Tax Carve-Out Provisions
Abstract
As Pillar Two’s 15% global minimum tax rules are progressively implemented and transposed into domestic legislation by various jurisdictions, host states’ tax regulatory measures may face challenges under the investor-State dispute settlement (ISDS) mechanism of international investment agreements. Measures taken by host states to implement the Global Anti-Base Erosion (GloBE) rules, such as revoking tax incentives and imposing top-up taxes, may be challenged by foreign investors in ISDS arbitration on grounds that such measures violate investment treaty obligations or constitute indirect expropriation. Tax carve-out provisions, as institutional mechanisms specifically addressing tax matters in international investment agreements, should in principle perform a jurisdictional bar function with respect to tax-related arbitration. However, they face significant challenges in the Pillar Two context. This article argues that the root cause of these challenges lies in the structural conflict between Pillar Two and ISDS. Pillar Two is a multilateral formula agreed upon by 139 jurisdictions, whereas the ISDS mechanism is predicated on a “host State-investor” bilateral confrontation paradigm and an assumption of unilateral bad faith. These two regimes exhibit fundamental misalignment in terms of rule attributes, review logic, and good faith assessment, and this structural misalignment has led to the progressive weakening of the jurisdictional bar function of tax carve-out provisions. In response, host states may rely on the treaty interpretation rules established under the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties (VCLT) to construct a systematic jurisdictional bar defence: (1) delineating the semantic boundaries of expropriation through “ordinary meaning”; (2) embedding multilateral normative considerations through “systemic integration”; and (3) anchoring tax sovereignty and establishing a robust good faith presumption through “object and purpose.” Through these three dimensions, host states may strengthen jurisdictional objections or treaty-based defences in Pillar Two-related disputes.Downloads
Published
2026-09-30
Issue
Section
Articles
License
Copyright (c) 2026 Zhimin Lu

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
How to Cite
Pillar Two and ISDS: The Structural Conflict and Treaty Interpretation Pathways to Strengthen the Jurisdictional Bar of Tax Carve-Out Provisions. (2026). CPS Digital Library - Series of Conferences, 1, 109-118. https://seriesofconference.com/index.php/SCJ/article/view/



