Recruitment and Selection: Assessment Methods, Predictive Validity, and Bias Reduction
Keywords:
Recruitment, Selection, Validity, Structured Interview, Assessment Center, Cognitive Ability, Predictive Validity, Schmidt Hunter, Adverse ImpactAbstract
Recruitment and selection play a critical role in determining workforce quality by identifying and choosing candidates who are most likely to perform effectively on the job. This paper reviews the major evidence-based employee selection methods, with particular attention to predictive validity, adverse impact, and the growing use of artificial intelligence in recruitment. Drawing on Schmidt and Hunter’s influential meta-analysis, the paper compares the validity of commonly used selection tools, including work sample tests, cognitive ability tests, structured and unstructured interviews, job knowledge tests, assessment centers, and experience-based criteria. The evidence shows that work samples, cognitive ability tests, and structured interviews are among the strongest predictors of job performance, whereas widely used methods such as unstructured interviews and years of experience demonstrate substantially lower validity. The paper further examines the trade-off between predictive validity and adverse impact, especially in the use of cognitive ability tests, which are highly predictive but may produce significant group differences in selection outcomes. Structured interviews are presented as a more standardized and comparatively less biased approach, as they rely on job-relevant questions, consistent evaluation criteria, and behaviorally anchored rating scales. In addition, the paper discusses the rapid adoption of AI-powered recruitment tools, including automated resume screening, chatbots, video interview analysis, and gamified assessments. Although these technologies may improve efficiency and standardization, current evidence regarding their validity, fairness, and legal compliance remains mixed, and biased historical training data may reproduce or amplify existing discrimination. Overall, the paper highlights the continuing gap between selection science and organizational practice and argues that future recruitment systems should combine strong predictive validity with greater fairness, transparency, and bias reduction.Downloads
Published
2023-12-31
Issue
Section
Articles
License
Copyright (c) 2026 Jinghan Yao

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
How to Cite
Recruitment and Selection: Assessment Methods, Predictive Validity, and Bias Reduction. (2023). CPS Digital Library - Series of Conferences, 7-9. https://seriesofconference.com/index.php/SCJ/article/view/419



