Climate Litigation: Theoretical Tension Between Judicial Activism and Judicial Restraint — Analysis of Rule-of-Law Models from a Comparative Law Perspective

Authors

  • Ziyao Shan Department of law, Suzhou City University, Suzhou, 224600, China

Keywords:

Climate Litigation, Judicial Activism, Judicial Restraint, Comparative Law, Rule-Of-Law Model

Abstract

Climate litigation has rapidly developed as a critical institutional channel for addressing global climate governance crises, and the judicial philosophy choice between judicial activism and judicial restraint runs through all core adjudication links of climate-related cases. From a comparative law perspective, different countries form differentiated rule-of-law operation models under the restraint of constitutional systems, legislative frameworks and judicial functional positioning, which continuously shape the theoretical tension between the two judicial doctrines. This paper sorts out the connotation and institutional boundaries of judicial activism and judicial restraint in climate litigation scenarios, compares the judicial practice paths of representative jurisdictions, analyzes the root causes of the persistent theoretical tension between the two doctrines, and explores a balanced judicial operation logic suitable for climate governance under the framework of the rule of law. This study adopts a comparative legal research method, combines typical climate judgment cases from Europe, North America and Oceania, and clarifies how institutional factors such as separation of powers, environmental statutory authorization and human rights judicialization affect judges’ choice of judicial stance, so as to provide reference for constructing standardized climate litigation judicial rules in China.

Downloads

Published

2026-11-21

How to Cite

Climate Litigation: Theoretical Tension Between Judicial Activism and Judicial Restraint — Analysis of Rule-of-Law Models from a Comparative Law Perspective. (2026). CPS Digital Library - Series of Conferences, 1-5. https://seriesofconference.com/index.php/SCJ/article/view/561