Functional Expansion of Preventive Environmental Injunctions in the Context of Climate Change: A Comparative Analysis of Chinese and U.S. Judicial Practice
Keywords:
Climate Change, Preventive Environmental Injunction, Climate Litigation, Comparative Environmental Law, Irreparable Harm, Precautionary PrincipleAbstract
Climate change challenges the temporal, causal, and remedial assumptions of traditional environmental adjudication. Harm may emerge gradually, result from cumulative emissions, cross territorial boundaries, and become irreversible before conventional liability is established. This paper examines whether preventive environmental injunctions can expand from stopping imminent local pollution to controlling serious climate-related risks. Through a comparative analysis of Chinese and U.S. practice, it argues that expansion is necessary but must remain calibrated. Chinese environmental adjudication offers a strong public-interest and risk-prevention orientation, while U.S. law supplies more developed doctrines on irreparable harm, standing, equitable balancing, remedial tailoring, and separation of powers. The paper proposes a differentiated six-factor test covering probability, severity and irreversibility, defendant contribution and control, urgency, proportionality, and enforceability. Scientific uncertainty should influence the scope and duration of relief rather than automatically defeat it. Negative or procedurally limited orders are generally more legitimate than broad structural commands requiring courts to design climate policy.Downloads
Published
2026-11-21
Issue
Section
Articles
License
Copyright (c) 2026 Yifan Zeng

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
How to Cite
Functional Expansion of Preventive Environmental Injunctions in the Context of Climate Change: A Comparative Analysis of Chinese and U.S. Judicial Practice. (2026). CPS Digital Library - Series of Conferences, 120-124. https://seriesofconference.com/index.php/SCJ/article/view/575



